EPDM rubber, GRP fibreglass and felt can all be suitable flat-roof coverings. The right choice depends on your roof's shape, the surface beneath it, drainage, insulation and how the edges and joints will be finished. We'll explain why those details matter alongside the material you choose.
We'll help you understand the differences between EPDM, GRP and felt, including preparation, drainage and future repairs. Use the comparison to discuss a complete roof for your garage or extension, rather than choosing on the covering alone.
First Make Sure the Quotes Describe the Same Roof
When you compare quotes, check that they cover the same roof area and construction. Is the old covering being removed or covered over? Does the price include decking, insulation, outlets and the edges? Tell us how you use the space below so we can discuss what the roof needs.
A rubber-roof quote that keeps the existing deck will include different work from a fibreglass quote that replaces it. An unheated garage roof also has different needs from the roof over your kitchen. Those differences can matter as much as the covering.
Use the flat-roof construction guide to understand what sits beneath the covering and what to check when comparing your options.
The Three Material Families
EPDM is a synthetic rubber membrane. Large sheets can reduce the number of seams on some roofs, but the edges, openings and wall junctions still need careful finishing. We'll explain the membrane and fittings proposed for your roof. [1]
GRP uses fibreglass reinforcement, resin and a surface finish over a suitable base. The preparation and fitting conditions matter, so your quote needs to identify the complete system being used. [2] [3]
Roofing felt usually means a reinforced bitumen roofing system, which differs from the lightweight felt often used on sheds. Check which layers, materials and fitting method are included, along with the care the finished roof will need. [4]
A Practical Comparison Table
| What to Compare | EPDM | GRP | Felt System |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main waterproofing form | Rubber membrane | Site-formed reinforced resin system | Reinforced bitumen sheets |
| What the quote should name | Which membrane, adhesive and compatible accessories? | The resin, reinforcement, finish and base | Which layers, products and installation method? |
| Roof shape | Sheet layout and details must suit the plan | Formed details must suit the system and substrate | Layer layout and details must suit the system |
| Weather during work | Component and substrate conditions matter | Temperature, dryness and curing requirements matter | Product and application conditions matter |
| Junctions | Fittings for edges, pipes and openings | Compatible trims and reinforced details | Raised edges, overlaps and edge fixings |
| Repairs | Identify the membrane and compatible repair method | Identify the system and condition before repair | Check the covering and damage before choosing a repair |
| Handover | Product identity, care and guarantee terms | Product identity, care and guarantee terms | Product identity, care and guarantee terms |
On small screens, scroll the table sideways to view every column.
Use these questions when comparing your quotes. Which system suits you will depend on the roof and the work it needs.
EPDM: Where the Detail Matters
A large rubber sheet can work well on a straightforward roof shape. Rooflights, pipes, corners and wall junctions still need the right fittings and finishing to keep water out.
We need to check the base beneath the membrane and how it will be fixed. If that base is damp or moving, covering it won't put the problem right. Ask us what can stay and what needs replacing.
The expected life of a rubber membrane is different from the guarantee on the complete roof. Our EPDM guide explains that distinction and the questions to ask about the proposed system.
GRP: Preparation and Conditions Are Important
A GRP roof needs more than a topcoat. The base, reinforcement, resin and finish must work together, including around edges and openings. We'll explain the proposed system and preparation in your quote.
Cure It's guidance shows why the weather and condition of the base matter during fitting. The requirements vary between products. Ask us which instructions apply to your roof and how poor weather could affect the work. [2]
A hard finish doesn't mean the roof is suitable for walking on or storing things. Tell us how you intend to use it so the structure, access and any protection can be considered separately.
Felt: Check the Layers and Materials Included
Felt systems vary in their products, layers and fitting methods. Your quote should name the proposed system and explain the guarantee that applies.
Check whether the price includes preparation, insulation, outlets and the finish around walls and edges. A quote for “new felt” is hard to compare without those details.
Where a fitting method involves heat or other hazards, safe working arrangements need to be planned. We'll discuss the work and access with you; those precautions are part of doing the job properly. [5]
Drainage Can Matter More Than the Material Debate
A new covering won't automatically fix a low spot or an outlet in the wrong place. Tell us where water collects so we can discuss whether the roof's slope or drainage also needs changing.
NFRC's summary of BS 6229:2025 highlights drainage slopes, surveys and handover records. When discussing your roof, ask how the finished slope will be achieved and checked, as well as which covering will be used. [6]
We'll also consider where water goes after leaving the roof. A blocked or poorly positioned gutter connection can cause problems even when the covering is sound.
Warm Roofs, Cold Roofs and Insulation
EPDM, GRP and felt keep rain out; they don't tell you where the insulation sits or how moisture is managed beneath them. We need to consider the complete roof and the room below.
IKO's flat-roof insulation guidance explains the importance of coordinated systems. Energy Saving Trust also advises professional installation for flat-roof insulation and assessment where damp is present. [7] [8]
Ask us to explain the proposed roof layers, any effect on adjoining windows or doors, and which insulation or approval requirements need checking. That gives you a clearer picture than a description such as “insulated roofing” on its own.
Costs, Lifespan and Guarantees
The cheapest covering isn't always the cheapest completed roof. Access, preparation, decking, insulation and the shape of the roof all affect the price. Compare the work included before relying on a cost per square metre.
Check who provides each guarantee, what it covers and any maintenance conditions. Product life, product warranties and workmanship guarantees mean different things. We'll explain the terms that apply to our proposed work.
The roof cost guide includes published national price examples and explains what to compare in a quote. The examples aren't fixed prices for our work.
How to Choose Your Flat-Roof Covering
We start by checking whether your roof can be repaired or needs replacing. We then consider the structure, decking, insulation and drainage before discussing the coverings that suit it.
Ask us why we're recommending a particular system. We should be able to explain how it suits your roof, including any difficult junctions or preparation it needs.
Before work starts, agree the materials, work and guarantee in writing. Keep those details and any photos afterwards; they can help if the roof needs maintenance or repairs later.
We offer EPDM, GRP, felt roofing and flat roof repairs for suitable properties in Newcastle, Gateshead and Sunderland. Use the quote page to tell us about your roof and discuss the options.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Is Best: EPDM, GRP or Felt?
That depends on your roof's base, shape, drainage and use. We can explain which complete systems suit it and what each quote includes, so you can compare more than the material name.
Is GRP Always Stronger Than EPDM?
GRP and EPDM behave differently. A hard surface isn't automatically suitable for regular foot traffic, and a flexible membrane isn't automatically less durable. We consider how you'll use the roof and the construction beneath it.
Are Modern Felt Roofs the Same as Shed Felt?
No. A roofing system can use different reinforcement, layers and fitting methods from lightweight shed felt. We'll explain the materials and work included in the proposed roof.
Can Any of These Systems Be Installed Over an Old Roof?
Sometimes, if the existing roof and chosen system allow it. We need to check for trapped moisture, damage, incompatible materials and changes in roof level before recommending an overlay.
Which Option Has the Longest Guarantee?
It depends on the products and the company providing the cover. Compare what is covered and the conditions, as well as the length of the guarantee. We'll make clear which product and workmanship guarantees apply to our quote.
Does a New Covering Fix Poor Drainage?
Not on its own. If the slope, outlets or gutter connections are causing the problem, those need attention too. Let us know about standing water before we quote.
Can I Walk on Any Flat Roof After Installation?
Don't assume it is safe. The structure and covering need to suit the intended access. Occasional maintenance access doesn't make a roof suitable as a terrace or storage space. Tell us what you have in mind before work is planned.
References & Sources
We have linked to the sources used in this guide so you can read more. They were checked on 27 September 2026. Manufacturer guidance applies to its own products, and published prices are examples rather than our quotes. Check the requirements for your project before arranging work. Links open in a new tab.
- Elevate RubberCover EPDM Residential Roofing System ↗ Manufacturer information on membrane options and expected longevity. We use it as a product example; it does not confirm an installer accreditation or the guarantee for your completed roof.
- Cure It Cure It: Frequently Asked Questions ↗ Guidance on the manufacturer's GRP system, the base beneath it and suitable installation conditions. The instructions for your chosen system should guide the work.
- Cure It Cure It Installation Guides ↗ Information about the components of a GRP roof, helping you check what is included beyond the visible topcoat.
- IKO Roof Maintenance Guidelines ↗ Maintenance advice for the manufacturer's applicable waterproofing systems. Your roof's condition, surroundings and guarantee terms should guide the inspection schedule.
- Health and Safety Executive Construction: Roof Work ↗ HSE advice on safe access and protection during roof work. Keep your own observations to safe positions, such as from the ground, and leave roof access to professionals.
- NFRC BS 6229:2025 Update: Key Points ↗ Published on 18 December 2025, this summary covers changes to the flat-roof code, including drainage falls, surveys, design and handover records.
- IKO Flat Roof Insulation ↗ Guidance on insulation within flat roofs. The whole roof construction needs checking; insulation thickness alone does not establish compliance.
- Energy Saving Trust Roof and Loft Insulation Guide ↗ Advice on roof insulation, ventilation and heat loss. The potential improvement depends on your home and the work proposed.
