Skip to main content
Family-Run North East Roofers • Free Quotes • Written Guarantees

Planning & Costs

How to Choose a Roofer: Questions, Quotes & Warning Signs

Choosing a roofer? Here are the questions we'd encourage you to ask about experience, insurance, the work included and your written guarantee.

Roofing advice from our team, with useful sources for further reading.

Explore All Roofing Guides →

A roofer should explain what they've found, what work they recommend and what the price includes. Reviews, experience and insurance are useful checks too. We'd encourage you to ask those questions of us or any other contractor before deciding who to use.

Use these questions when speaking to us or comparing other roofing companies. They cover the first conversation, the quote and what to agree before work starts.

Start with What You've Noticed

Give each company the same information: your address, the roof type if known, what's happening or what you'd like to change, safe photos and previous repairs. That helps you compare advice on the same job.

You don't need to know the cause before calling. Explain what you've noticed and ask how it will be investigated. Choosing a repair product before the fault is understood can make it harder to compare useful options.

If a surveyor has already reported on the roof, share the relevant section rather than paraphrasing only the conclusion. A recommendation to investigate a hidden detail is different from a confirmed need to replace a whole roof.

Nineteen Questions Worth Asking

Nineteen Questions Worth Asking
Question What the Answer Should Explain
1. Who is the contracting business? The legal or trading identity and reliable contact details
2. What relevant roofing experience can you show? Work comparable in type and complexity, not just any building work
3. What have you actually inspected? Areas seen, access used and limitations
4. What is causing the problem? What's been found and what still needs checking
5. Why is this option recommended? What repair, partial work or replacement would achieve
6. Which roof areas are included? Main slopes, extensions, bays, garages or exclusions
7. What products and components are proposed? The actual products and fittings to be used
8. What remains in place? The condition and suitability of retained materials
9. How will access and protection be managed? A suitable plan for the particular property
10. Who checks permissions and building control? Named responsibilities and any separate fees
11. Which other trades are involved? Any work involving windows, solar panels or appliances
12. What insurance applies to this work? Which current insurance covers the proposed job
13. Is the price a quotation or an estimate? What is fixed, provisional or still unknown
14. Does the total include VAT and waste? The full amount you will pay
15. How are unforeseen findings handled? How extra work will be shown, priced and approved
16. What payment schedule is proposed? Clear milestones and terms
17. What happens if weather interrupts work? How the roof is protected and changes are agreed
18. What guarantee and handover documents are supplied? Who provides the cover, what it covers and its conditions
19. How are concerns handled after completion? A clear contact and complaints process

On small screens, scroll the table sideways to view every column.

Use these questions to guide your conversation and compare the answers. They can help you choose, but they don't replace checking a contractor's experience and suitability for the job.

Check Experience, Insurance and Memberships

Ask for relevant examples and check any claimed membership or accreditation with the organisation concerned. Do not assume that a logo in a quotation proves current membership, or that a review-platform profile is the same as a technical qualification.

Check that insurance covers the business and the work you're hiring it for. Insurance, product certification and a workmanship guarantee serve different purposes; one doesn't replace the others.

Citizens Advice recommends checking the trader, insurance and permissions, and getting written quotes. Its guidance also explains why a cheaper quote may include less work. [1]

Ask What Has Been Found and Why It Needs Work

When we recommend work, ask what we've confirmed and what remains uncertain. If replacement is proposed, you should understand why a repair wouldn't be suitable. If a local repair is proposed, check exactly what it covers.

Be wary of anyone who says every old roof needs replacing or any roof can be made maintenance-free. Ask them to show you the problem and explain why the proposed work is right for your roof.

The repair-or-replacement guide helps you compare the options. If the condition is unclear or the work is substantial, an independent professional opinion may also help you decide.

Make Quotations Comparable

Check that each quote covers the same areas, scaffolding, removal, materials, insulation and roof junctions. Note anything excluded or allowed for only provisionally before comparing totals.

A proposal that renews chimney flashings and a proposal that retains them are not identical. A price excluding access or VAT should not be compared directly with an inclusive total. Our cost guide shows why checking the work included can change which quote appears cheaper.

Ask for anything you've clarified during a visit to be included in the written quote. That helps everyone understand what has been agreed.

Safe Access Is Part of the Job

Safe access is part of the cost of roofing work. Ask how it will be arranged, and check that a cheaper quote hasn't simply left it out. Even a low roof or short job can involve fragile surfaces, openings and unprotected edges. [2] [3]

Tell us about conservatories, shared entrances, restricted parking and anything else that affects access. We'll discuss which areas need keeping clear and how the people using the building will be informed.

You shouldn't have to climb onto your roof to check a problem or the finished work. Ask for photographs and an explanation instead.

Understand the Contract and Payment Terms

Read the work, timing, payments, process for extra work and cancellation terms before agreeing. Keep the business details and a copy of what you've accepted, including messages; an informal exchange can still form part of an agreement.

Cancellation rights vary with how the contract was made and whether work has already been requested or started. Citizens Advice explains the rules and exceptions. Check the terms for your circumstances, particularly for urgent repairs. [4]

If hidden damage is found, ask to see what has changed and what extra work is needed. Agree the revised work and price in writing before it goes ahead.

Check Who Provides the Guarantee and What It Covers

Ask whether the guarantee covers materials, workmanship or something else. Check who provides it, how long it lasts, what's excluded and any maintenance or registration requirements. If you're unsure about our terms, ask us to explain them before deciding.

A roofing guarantee won't necessarily cover unrelated damp, every chimney issue or alterations made later. Keep any required completion documents as well as the guarantee.

Keep the handover documents with the property's records. This helps if a concern arises, if another trade needs to work on the roof or if the property is later sold.

If Something Goes Wrong

If you're concerned about our work, tell us promptly, describe the issue and refer to the agreed quote. Keep photos and correspondence. Give the business responsible the chance to discuss the problem before arranging other treatments, unless urgent action is needed for safety or to limit damage.

Citizens Advice explains routes for dealing with work that is not as agreed or has not been carried out with the required care. A dangerous structure or electrical risk requires an appropriate safety response rather than waiting for a routine complaint. [5]

If a contract, payment or proposed remedy is disputed, get advice on your particular circumstances. The consumer guidance linked here can help you find a starting point.

Discussing a Quote with Emperor Roofing

We're a family-run roofing business, and you can speak directly to Peter or Robert. We provide roofing services for suitable properties in Newcastle, Gateshead, Sunderland and the wider North East.

Please ask us these questions too. Send your property details through our quote page and we'll discuss the work, relevant insurance and guarantee for your job. We want you to understand the quote before deciding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I Always Choose the Cheapest Roofer?

Not necessarily. A cheaper quote may leave out access equipment, disposal, insulation or important roof details. Check that you're comparing the same work, materials and responsibilities.

Are Good Online Reviews Enough?

Reviews can help, but check relevant experience, business details, the proposed work and the written quote too. Verify any claimed accreditation or membership separately.

Is an Estimate the Same as a Fixed Quote?

No. Ask which parts of the price are fixed and what could change. Any allowances, exclusions and further checks should be clear before you accept it.

Does Every Roofing Job Have a Fourteen-Day Cancellation Period?

The answer depends on how the contract was made and the circumstances, including relevant exceptions and work already requested. Read the cancellation information and obtain consumer advice where needed. Do not assume every arrangement has the same terms.

What Should Happen When Hidden Damage Is Found?

We'll explain what has been found, how it affects the job and any change to the price or timing. The process for approving extra work should be agreed before the roof is opened up, with changes confirmed in writing.

Does a Long Guarantee Prove a Better Roof?

A longer guarantee is only useful if you understand what it covers, who provides it and any conditions. A product warranty and a roofer's workmanship guarantee cover different things, so compare the terms as well as the duration.

Can I Ask for an Independent Opinion?

Yes. An independent surveyor or other relevant specialist can help where a major recommendation is uncertain. Agree what you need checked and obtain the owner's permission for access if the property isn't yours.

References & Sources

We have linked to the sources used in this guide so you can read more. They were checked on 27 September 2026. Manufacturer guidance applies to its own products, and published prices are examples rather than our quotes. Check the requirements for your project before arranging work. Links open in a new tab.

  1. Citizens Advice Before You Get Work Done on Your Home ↗ Citizens Advice guidance for England on choosing a trader, getting written quotes, checking insurance and agreeing permissions.
  2. Health and Safety Executive Construction: Roof Work ↗ HSE advice on safe access and protection during roof work. Keep your own observations to safe positions, such as from the ground, and leave roof access to professionals.
  3. Health and Safety Executive Fragile Surfaces ↗ HSE explains why roofs and rooflights may be fragile, and why precautions are needed even for a short maintenance job.
  4. Citizens Advice Cancelling Building or Decorating Work ↗ An explanation of cancellation rights and the exceptions that may apply. Your rights depend on how the contract was agreed and when work starts.
  5. Citizens Advice Problems with Building Work or Home Improvements ↗ Citizens Advice guidance for England on raising problems with a trader and keeping records of agreed work. It also explains what to do about dangerous structures.
Call Peter 07498 297937 Free Quote Call Robert 07777 166851